Goodreads | Amazon | Bookshop.org (UK) | Book Depository | Hive
Publisher: Orbit Books
Publish Date: 10 September 2019
Page Count: 374 pages
I’ve had Ten Thousand Doors of January for months but postponed reading it as I’d recently finished Seanan McGuire’s Wayward Children series and felt my portal fantasy quota had been met for the year. However, I’m glad I picked it up as part of my Hugo Award readathon for #Readerswithoutborders, as it’s an entirely different take on magical doorways.
If you haven’t already, please consider donating to the Doctors Without Borders JustGiving page for your chance to win a book! So far we have four supporters and three books to give away, so your chances of making your money back are excellent!
The Ten Thousand Doors of January is set after the turn of the 20th century, in a time of peace and progress when trade and exploration highlight the vastness of the world while simultaneously making it feel smaller. January is the young ward of Mr William Cornelius Locke, living on his Vermont estate while her father is paid to travel to remote parts of the world, seeking rare and exotic items to add to Mr Locke’s collection.
“When you travel with money, you follow a smooth, well-worn path through the world. Wood-panelled train cars lead to shiny black cabs, which lead to hotel rooms with velvet curtains, each step effortlessly following the last.”
While January grows up living a comfortable life and is often permitted to accompany Mr Locke on his business trips, she has a wild and imaginative spirit. Impatient for bigger adventures, she struggles to maintain her patron’s idea of a perfect society girl.
When January finds a mysterious book containing stories of portals and a woman who travels between them, it inspires her to embrace her imagination and her true self. This triggers a series of events theat will reveal just how much she shares with the woman and her magical doors.
“The hour-dragons stalked me. They grew larger as the sun set, multiplying in the shadows.”
Harrow is a master of metaphor and simile. She uses glittering prose that speaks to all five senses and dry, whimsical observations that often put a smile on my face.
“My dress that year was a shapeless froth of pink ribbons and frills that made me look like a rather sulky cupcake.”
This book is worth a read purely to experience her writing style.
At first, I thought this was going to be a period book to enjoy leisurely, perhaps while sitting under a parasol on a grassy knoll, eating fresh cucumber sandwiches. But what begins as a simple story about the desire for freedom of expression becomes about so many other things; love, greed, control, and the power of change. Vivid characters bring a truthful perspective to childhood, parenthood, fatherhood, motherhood and even interdimensional ‘hoods.
One of the very few problems I had with this book is the uncomfortable depiction of 20th-century racism in the absence of any other device used to reflect the period of the book. Harrow’s dialogue feels anachronistic in comparison to books like Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell or The Memoirs of Lady Trent series, which have a more authentic rather than a modern vibe. Although, I know that Harrow is a historian in African American history and has the knowledge to support writing accurately about these topics, and it makes sense to write what you know (edit upon publishing post: I wrote this last month before Black Lives Matter was frequently talked about on book blogs and Twitter. I’m in the process of educating myself, and I understand that white authors can still write validly about racism. It is better that Harrow chose to be historically accurate about racism if not other aspects of the novel, perhaps even doing so to bring these themes into the spotlight).
I also wish there was a more stylistic distinction between Harrow’s narration and that of her characters’, given her choice to include entire chapters from January’s book and to use multiple POVs from characters with very different backgrounds. These were minor observations that only held the book back from being a perfect experience, perhaps spawned in the fog of nightshift-grumpiness through which I read it.
Overall, like many other readers, I adored the Ten Thousand Doors of January. It’s a fantastic and emotional journey that includes one of the most realistic, moving and gender-stereotype-free romances I can recall reading in fiction.
See that capital ‘O’? Like the yawning mouth of a portal to another world, summoning you to an adventure? I suggest you step through it.
Trigger warning: Please note that this book contains cutting/self-harm
Support independent bookstores and my blog by buying from bookshop.org
5 thoughts on “The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E. Harrow”
I read this last month and loved it! It was such an adventure.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s not what I expected at all!
I know lots of bloggers who enjoyed this book, but I could not get into it at all! It sounds like something I would like…maybe I’ll have to give it another shot some day. I appreciate your comments on the depiction of racism in the book, and the acknowledgement of the current context and the author’s experience.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Jenna! I think because I didn’t think this book would be for me I was pleasantly surprised. It does have some odd pacing in the beginning but it does pick up!
LikeLiked by 1 person